Watch: what makes aviation cases different
The possible defendants
- The pilot (or the pilot’s estate): pilot error — fuel planning, weather decisions, loss of control — is a factor in many general-aviation crashes.
- The owner or operator: who authorized the flight, who maintained the plane, and whether the flight was really an illegal charter. A federal law (49 U.S.C. § 44112) limits the liability of owners and lessors who were not in actual possession or operational control of the aircraft.
- Maintenance and repair shops: missed inspections, improper repairs, and signed-off work that wasn’t done.
- Manufacturers of the airframe, engine, or components, subject to GARA (below).
- Fuel and ground-service providers: contaminated or wrong fuel, improper servicing.
- Air traffic control: claims against FAA-employed controllers go through the Federal Tort Claims Act — an administrative claim within two years, then suit within six months of a denial. Some towers are run by private contractors, which changes the analysis.
GARA: the 18-year rule for manufacturers
The General Aviation Revitalization Act of 1994 bars most claims against a manufacturer if the accident happened more than 18 years after the aircraft was delivered. It applies to aircraft with fewer than 20 passenger seats not in scheduled passenger service. But the clock restarts for any replaced or added part alleged to have caused the crash, and GARA doesn’t apply if the manufacturer concealed or misrepresented required safety information from the FAA, if the victim was not on board, if the passenger was being flown for medical emergency treatment, or if there is a written warranty claim. Many old aircraft have newer engines and components — which is where the key evidence is often found.
Florida adds its own limit: for most private aircraft, product-liability claims are generally barred 12 years after delivery to the first buyer (Fla. Stat. § 95.031(2)(b)); aircraft used in commercial or charter service get 20 years. Exceptions exist for concealed defects and injuries that show up later. A claim may have to clear both the Florida and the federal rules.
The NTSB investigation — and its limits
The National Transportation Safety Board investigates civil aviation accidents. Its “party system” lets the FAA, manufacturers, and operators help — but no one who represents claimants or insurers can participate (49 C.F.R. § 831.11). By federal law, the Board’s report, including its probable cause finding, can’t be admitted or used in a civil damages case (49 U.S.C. § 1154(b)); investigators’ factual reports are treated differently. Families need their own independent investigation.
Preserve the wreckage
After the NTSB is done, wreckage is released — often to the owner’s insurer, which may store, sell, or scrap it. An engine, a fuel servo, or a control cable can be the whole case. A preservation demand and an evidence-protocol agreement should go out immediately.
Wrongful death and deadlines
Florida’s Wrongful Death Act lets the personal representative recover for the survivors (lost support and services, loss of companionship, mental pain and suffering, medical and funeral expenses) and the estate. For crashes at sea more than three nautical miles from shore, federal law (the Death on the High Seas Act) may apply instead, and it generally limits recovery to financial losses. Florida’s deadline is generally two years for negligence and for wrongful death (Fla. Stat. § 95.11(5)(a), (e)), and four years for injury claims based on a defective product (§ 95.11(3)(d)).
A former defense lawyer’s take
I ran a product-liability practice group on the defense side. In aviation cases, the defense wants the crash to be “pilot error” — because a dead pilot’s estate often has the least insurance, and it keeps the manufacturers out. The families who get full answers are the ones whose lawyers get to the wreckage, the maintenance logs, and the parts history before the story is settled.
Frequently asked questions
Who can be sued after a private plane crash in Florida?
Potentially the pilot or pilot’s estate, the owner or operator, maintenance shops, manufacturers of the aircraft or parts, fuel or ground-service providers, and in some cases the FAA for air traffic control errors.
What is GARA?
The General Aviation Revitalization Act of 1994. It generally bars claims against manufacturers of small aircraft and parts more than 18 years after delivery — but the 18 years restart for replaced parts, and there are exceptions such as concealment from the FAA. Florida also has its own 12-year product-liability repose for most private aircraft (Fla. Stat. § 95.031(2)(b)).
Can the NTSB report be used in my lawsuit?
Not the Board’s report or probable-cause finding — federal law bars it in civil damages cases (49 U.S.C. § 1154(b)). Investigators’ factual reports are treated differently, but an independent investigation is essential.
How long do families have to file a plane crash lawsuit in Florida?
Generally two years for negligence and for wrongful death, and four years for injury claims based on a defective product. Claims against the FAA require an administrative claim within two years under the Federal Tort Claims Act, then suit within six months of a denial.
What happens to the wreckage after a crash?
The NTSB releases it after its investigation, often to the owner’s insurer. It should be preserved immediately through a written demand and an agreed inspection protocol.
Talk to a former insurance-defense attorney
You'll speak with Emanuel Galimidi. He spent nearly two decades on the insurance side. Now he's on yours. The case review is free, and there are no fees or costs unless we recover for you.
Call 786-442-2873