Why the adjuster calls so fast
The call often comes within a day or two. That is before you know how badly you are hurt, and before you have talked to a lawyer. That timing is not an accident. On the defense side, an early recorded statement is one of the most valuable things an insurance company can get. That's because you do not yet know what you do not know.
What they are really fishing for
The questions sound like small talk. They are not. The insurance company's adjuster is listening for a few specific things:
- An early “I’m okay” or “just a little sore.” They can use it later to argue that your injuries are minor or did not come from the crash.
- Any hint of fault — “I didn’t really see him” — which is worth far more now under Florida’s 51% comparative-fault rule.
- Prior injuries or treatment they can blame instead of the crash.
The other side's insurance company vs. your own insurance company
There is a key distinction. You have no obligation to give a recorded statement to the other driver’s insurance company — they are not on your side, and you can simply decline. Your own policy is different: most policies contain a cooperation clause, and if you are making a claim under your own coverage — for example, an uninsured-motorist claim — you may be required to cooperate. Even then, you can have a lawyer present and prepare beforehand.
How an early “I’m fine” becomes a defense exhibit
Soft-tissue injuries (muscles and ligaments) and spine injuries often do not show up for several days. The problem is that your recorded “I feel fine” was captured on day one. When a doctor diagnoses you a week later, they replay that early statement to argue the injury came from something else. I used those recordings to defend claims. They work.
What to do when the adjuster calls
You do not have to be rude, and you do not have to refuse to talk at all. Keep it simple. Be polite. Confirm who is calling and which company they work for. Give basic facts about who you are. Then say no, politely, to a recorded statement until you have talked to a lawyer. You are allowed to say no. A real claim does not depend on how well you do in a recorded interview that the other side controls.
A former defense lawyer’s bottom line
For nearly two decades, I was the lawyer those statements were collected for. The single best thing most people can do after a crash is slow things down. See a doctor. Understand your injuries. Get advice before you go on record. Rushing into a recorded statement almost never helps you, and a lot can go wrong.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to give the other driver's insurance a recorded statement in Florida?
No. You are not required to give a recorded statement to the at-fault driver's insurance company, and you can decline.
Can I refuse to give a recorded statement?
Yes, to the other side's insurance company. You can politely say no and talk to a lawyer first. Your own insurance company may be different, because of the cooperation clause in your policy.
What about my own insurance company?
Your policy likely has a cooperation clause. That means if you make a claim under your own coverage, you may have to cooperate with your own insurance company. You can still prepare first and have a lawyer involved.
What should I say when an insurance adjuster calls?
Be polite. Confirm who is calling and which company they work for. Give basic facts about who you are. Then say no, politely, to a recorded statement until you have talked to a lawyer.
Why do adjusters want a recorded statement so quickly?
To get your answers on record before you know how badly you are hurt, and before you have talked to a lawyer. Early answers are easier to use to make your injury look smaller.
Talk to a former insurance-defense attorney
You'll speak with Emanuel Galimidi. He spent nearly two decades on the insurance side. Now he's on yours. The case review is free, and there are no fees or costs unless we recover for you.
Get your free case review